MLB Power Rankings: West Coast contenders shake things up


With Major League Baseball teams reaching the midpoint of their seasons and next week’s trade deadline looming ahead on the sports calendar, even little more than a month’s worth of data is starting to take on meaning for general managers weighing decisions about potential moves they can make. Not least because there’s little more than a month of regular-season baseball left to go in 2020’s time-crunched campaign.

That limited time to make these judgments also moved our dozen voters in this week’s Power Rankings to make some key calls. The Dodgers may still rule the roost as a unanimous No. 1, but the A’s and Rays barged past the Yankees to round out a new top three. The Padres bumped the slumping Rockies from our top 10. And watch out for the Cardinals and the Blue Jays, who are both starting to climb as they get more games in.

With the drama starting to mount as the races take shape, national baseball writer David Schoenfield and senior editor Christina Kahrl offered their key stats for every team.

Statistics through Saturday.

Previous: Preseason | Week 1 | Week 2 | Week 3

Record: 22-8
Week 3 ranking: 1

The Dodgers lead the National League in runs per game and fewest runs per game allowed. The last NL team to do that? The 2019 Dodgers! The last NL team before that? The 2018 Dodgers. Before 2018, the Dodgers last led the NL in runs in 1978.

ICYMI: Vintage Kershaw key to Dodgers’ title quest

Record: 20-9
Week 3 ranking: 3

The bullpen has been the huge key so far, ranking second in the majors to the Dodgers with a 2.10 ERA, while ranking first in win probability added and going 9-2. After blowing a save on Opening Day, closer Liam Hendriks is 9-for-9 in saves and has allowed just one run in 13⅓ innings.

ICYMI: Are Billy Beane’s A’s cursed?

Record: 19-10
Week 3 ranking: 6

With Yonny Chirinos out for the season because of Tommy John surgery, that is now four Rays pitchers out for the year, including Colin Poche, Brendan McKay and Andrew Kittredge. The Rays have thrived despite having just one quality start in their first 28 games — tied with the Pirates for fewest in MLB.

ICYMI: Add closer Anderson to Rays’ rash of pitching injuries

Record: 16-9
Week 3 ranking: 2

Luke Voit led the American League with a 1.115 OPS entering Sunday (second in the majors behind Bryce Harper), hitting .311/.386/.730. The last Yankees player to lead the AL was Alex Rodriguez in 2007 and the last Yankee first baseman to lead was Don Mattingly in 1986.

ICYMI: Bullpen chess match could define Rays-Yanks race

Record: 19-10
Week 3 ranking: 5

Nelson Cruz is among the AL leaders with a 1.074 OPS. Cruz is 40 years old but is considered to be in his age-39 season (even though all his games this season came after turning 40). Cruz’s 192 OPS+ would rank second among age-39 seasons: Barry Bonds 2004 (263), Cruz 2020 (192), Ted Williams 1958 (179), Babe Ruth 1934 (160), David Ortiz 2015 (140).

ICYMI: Maeda could cure Twins’ October woes

Record: 17-10
Week 3 ranking: 4

The Cubs are hitting just .225 but do lead the majors with a 11.7% walk rate, so they at least rank fourth in MLB in OBP. Still, their .732 OPS ranks just 18th. Kyle Schwarber (36.7% strikeout rate compared to 25.6% last year) and Javier Baez (33.7% compared to 27.8%) continue to have contact problems.

ICYMI: Which reliever could Cubs land at deadline?

Record: 15-13
Week 3 ranking: 10

Last year, with the addition of Yordan Alvarez midway through the season, Astros DHs hit .275/.367/.554 with 42 home runs and 111 RBIs. This year, with Alvarez playing just two games and now out for the season, their DHs are hitting .206/.308/.353 with three home runs.

ICYMI: Astros’ deadline priority? Starting pitching

Record: 16-12
Week 3 ranking: 7

It’s hard to believe, but entering Sunday, Max Fried remains the only Atlanta starter to win a game. He’s 4-0 with a 1.32 ERA and the rest of the rotation is 0-8 with a 6.86 ERA. Atlanta relievers are 12-3, however, as the Braves are 6-2 in one-run games.

ICYMI: What the Braves could do for deadline deals

Record: 17-11
Week 3 ranking: 9

Triston McKenzie‘s dazzling 10-strikeout debut on Saturday — the first pitcher to strike out at least 10 in his first start since Freddy Peralta in 2018 — was just the latest gem by a Cleveland starter. Cleveland’s rotation leads the majors in ERA (2.80), quality starts (19, four more than any other team), strikeouts, strikeout rate and OBP allowed.

ICYMI: Phenom McKenzie K’s 10 in debut



Eric Hosmer says fans are starting to catch on that Fernando Tatis Jr. is going to be the face of baseball.

Record: 18-12
Week 3 ranking: 11

It was a historic week for the Padres. They became the first team to hit a grand slam in four consecutive games and then Jake Cronenworth hit one Saturday, giving them five in six games. During that six-game win streak, they hit 17 home runs and scored 51 runs (8.5 per game).

ICYMI: Tatis, Soto breaking the unwritten rules — and it’s great

Record: 17-12
Week 3 ranking: 12

The Sox entered Sunday tied with the Padres for the MLB lead with 54 home runs. The White Sox were just 25th in the majors in home runs in 2019. In their seven-game win streak entering Sunday, they bashed 27 home runs, including two games with six.

ICYMI: Luis Robert on adapting to life in the big leagues

Record: 11-14
Week 3 ranking: 13

With Stephen Strasburg out for the season, the Nationals were confronted with the problem of their rotation depth, as just Max Scherzer and Patrick Corbin had thrown a quality start in 2020 before Anibal Sanchez spun his first good turn of the season on Sunday. As muddled as the NL playoff field is, they’ll need more of that.

ICYMI: Strasburg to have season-ending surgery

Record: 13-15
Week 3 ranking: 8

That 11-3 start feels like a long time ago, as the Rockies fell under .500 with Saturday’s loss. They hit .268/.335/.442 in their first 14 games but went .253/.306/.401 in their next 13. The team ERA increased from 2.88 to 6.06.

ICYMI: Are Rockies doomed to be also-rans at altitude?

Record: 11-15
Week 3 ranking: 14

Despite their many moves in the offseason, the 2020 Reds are a lot like the 2019 Reds: good rotation, below-average offense and late-game bullpen issues. The bullpen is 25th in the majors in win probability added and the lineup entered Sunday hitting just .210. Eugenio Suarez is at .145 and Joey Votto, after homering in the first two games of the season, has hit .186 with one home run.

ICYMI: Will Reds target catching help?

Record: 9-8
Week 3 ranking: 19

The Cardinals have had to piece together their rotation — using nine different starters in their first 16 games — but it has a 3.52 ERA and .195 batting average allowed. There’s been some good fortune in there with a .218 BABIP. Getting Jack Flaherty back with no limits will help, as he was limited to 41 pitches in his first start back from the COVID layoff.

ICYMI: Why Cardinals should trade for a starting pitcher

Record: 11-15
Week 3 ranking: 15

While the Brewers have struggled to break out initially, the late-game bullpen trio of Josh Hader, Devin Williams and David Phelps had combined for an incredible 45 strikeouts in 27 innings pitched through Saturday while allowing just two earned runs, giving Milwaukee the sort of edge that keeps any close game in reach for its slow-starting offense — and could make the Brewers a fearsome playoff opponent if they make it.

Record: 12-14
Week 3 ranking: 18

Dominic Smith didn’t play much early on, but Yoenis Cespedes’ departure opened up some playing time and he has been on fire with a .323/.403/.754 line, including 16 extra-base hits (10 doubles, six home runs) in just 65 at-bats. That’s an incredible pace of 123 extra-base hits in 500 at-bats.

ICYMI: Why the NL East race could go the distance

Record: 13-13
Week 3 ranking: 23

Teoscar Hernandez hit his 10th home run on Sunday — when he connects, he hits it hard, ranking in the 99th percentile in average exit velocity and hard-hit rate. The strikeout-to-walk ratio is ugly, so you’d love to see him cut down on that chase rate (34%) and put more balls in play.

ICYMI: Jays put prospect Pearson on IL

Record: 10-14
Week 3 ranking: 16

Well, it ain’t Bryce Harper‘s fault. He leads the majors with a 1.192 OPS, hitting .343/.478/.714. He’s gotten off to hot starts before, but his approach has been a little different this year with a much more aggressive first-pitch mindset, swinging 49.5% of the time on the first pitch, up from 43% last year (and up from 29% in 2016).

ICYMI: Phillies nab Workman, Hembree to shore up pen

Record: 13-16
Week 3 ranking: 24

Zac Gallen is proving his 2019 rookie season was no fluke, as he has a 2.25 ERA through six starts with 42 K’s in 36 innings and has yet to allow more than two runs in a game. The weird thing is he has no decisions. The Diamondbacks are 4-2 in his starts, however.

Record: 11-11
Week 3 ranking: 17

The Marlins are in the playoff race thanks to some timely hitting. They’re hitting .241/.320/.375 overall, but they’re batting .291 with runners on base and .270/.354/.484 in high-leverage situations. Brian Anderson is hitting just .225, but he’s at .389 with runners in scoring position and .357 in high-leverage moments.

ICYMI: Rojas, first Fish to get COVID-19, back in action

Record: 10-17
Week 3 ranking: 22

The Rangers aren’t quite last in batting average on balls in play, but they’re among the worst at .262 in part thanks to some bad luck by leading the AL in hard-hit outs with 70. With no Rangers regular outside of Joey Gallo off to a strong start, Texas needs a teamwide reversal of fortune on contact.

Record: 9-20
Week 3 ranking: 20

With 10 home runs, Mike Trout is among the MLB leaders. But if L.A. doesn’t get turned around soon — and if Trout wins another MVP award — he could join Andre Dawson (1987, NL) and Alex Rodriguez (2003, AL) as just the third MVP ever to come from a last-place team. Part of the problem? Angels DHs, first basemen and corner outfielders have combined for MLB worsts in OPS (.593) and wOBA (.256).



Tom VanHaaren details the news that a Mike Trout rookie card was sold for just under $4 million, setting the record for the highest-selling sports card.

Record: 14-14
Week 3 ranking: 21

If you want a stat that exemplifies the O’s improbable run to relevance in the early going, Baltimore leading the majors in outs made at home plate with six might be it. After all, if you’re the Orioles, why not go for it? What’s the worst that could happen? Having snapped last week’s losing streak with a pair of weekend wins over the Red Sox, the streaky O’s might avoid a fourth straight season in the basement.

Record: 9-20
Week 3 ranking: 26

The Red Sox have never drafted first overall, but they certainly have a chance to obtain that dubious honor for 2021. Their highest picks came in the first three drafts: fifth in 1965 (Billy Conigliaro), fourth in 1966 (Ken Brett) and third in 1967 (Mike Garman). Since then, their highest pick has been seventh in 1993 (Trot Nixon), 2013 (Trey Ball) and 2015 (Andrew Benintendi).

ICYMI: Should Sox trade Bogaerts at deadline?

Record: 11-17
Week 3 ranking: 27

Trevor Rosenthal is already a much-discussed option for teams looking for bullpen help at the deadline, but he’s just one of three thirtysomething relievers in K.C. with 30-save seasons in their history who are also all free agents at season’s end. Rosenthal had seasons with 45 (2014) and 48 saves (2015), Greg Holland notched an NL-best 41 in an All-Star season in 2017 and Ian Kennedy had 30 for the Royals just last year.

ICYMI: George Brett and the magic of chasing .400

Record: 14-16
Week 3 ranking: 28

The best player in the majors? Well, entering Sunday it wasn’t Fernando Tatis Jr., who led position players in FanGraphs WAR, but Mike Yastrzemski (2.1 to 2.0). Yaz is hitting .311/.434/.632 with 27 runs and 22 RBIs in 29 games. (And he homered on Sunday — on his birthday!)

ICYMI: Giants designate Pence for assignment

Record: 11-15
Week 3 ranking: 25

An MLB-worst 7.63 ERA from the Tigers’ rotation might sound like grim tidings, but it has created an opportunity for the team’s much-anticipated changing of the guard as it starts phasing in pitching phenoms such as Casey Mize and Tarik Skubal, both of whom debuted last week.

ICYMI: Top prospect Mize impresses in MLB debut

Record: 11-19
Week 3 ranking: 29

Kyle Lewis continues to rake — .373/.463/.569, leading the AL in OBP and hits. He also has drawn 18 walks. In his call-up last September, he had a 33.7% chase rate, but it’s down to 20.8%. It’s an interesting profile, as his hard-hit rate is actually just in the 23rd percentile and his strikeout rate is below average. Obviously, the .464 BABIP will decline, but the improved approach is a big positive.

ICYMI: M’s trade 2019 All-Star Vogelbach to Blue Jays

Record: 7-17
Week 3 ranking: 30

The Pirates’ season has been ill-starred from the start, but sweeping the Brewers over the weekend reflects their changing fortunes. With Gregory Polanco, Colin Moran, Adam Frazier and Erik Gonzalez all underperforming their expected wOBA by 50 points or more, a teamwide offensive resurgence wouldn’t be a surprise.

ICYMI: Bucs’ Bell among top deadline targets

Products You May Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *